By Hayden Wright

The canon of popular Christmas music is a hard playlist to crack: Apart from Mariah Carey’s “All I Want for Christmas Is You” and Wham!’s “Last Christmas,” most standards we love are oldies but goodies. That doesn’t stop artists from trying their luck: In 2000, Britney Spears recorded “My Only Wish (This Year)” and among her fans, its legacy endures.

Related: Britney Spears Posts Elvis Presley Cover to Celebrate Her 36th Birthday

One such fan is comedian John Early, who appeared on The Late Show and performed Britney’s holiday classic. The Search Party actor explained what makes “My Only Wish (This Year)” so special to him:

“As a devout atheist, Christmas is huge for me, especially Christmas music. So I’m going to sing you my favorite Christmas song if that’s okay,” he said. “I’m gonna sing a song by Ms. Britney Jean Spears, who I coincidentally do a shocking impression of, born completely out of love, by the way.”

Watch Early’s cover rendition below.

More From Today's 96.5

Justin Timberlake's "Man of the Woods Tour" is Coming to Philly!!!Circle June 2nd on your calendar, because Justin Timberlake is coming to the Wells Fargo Center!
Taylor Swift at Lincoln Financial Field July 13th AND 14th!In addition to July 14th, Taylor Swift has added a second show on Friday, July 13th at Lincoln Financial Field!

Listen Live